Select one of the keywords
Pantheons    by E. J. Dabel order for
by E. J. Dabel
Order:  USA  Can
Sea Lion, 2011 (2011)
*   Reviewed by Ricki Marking-Camuto

The Greek gods tend to get all of the glory when it comes to novels based on mythology. E. J. Dabel tries to rectify that in his new series, Pantheons, which incorporates gods from different cultures in a unique underdog story.

Living under a bridge since the death of his mother at the hands of his father, Isaiah Marshall is the leader of his gang, the Redrovers. Due to a speech impediment, Isaiah never speaks, but the other boys cannot help but follow him. One day, he and his three friends find themselves on the wrong block, getting harassed by a prep school kid, and then by the vice principal who wants the boys off school grounds.

The principal, though, has another idea and invites the boys to attend Kaliber Academy. It turns out, the principal knows a secret about Isaiah; he knows that Isaiah is the son of Greek gods and Kaliber Academy is the school that many of them attend, being stuck on Earth in the bodies of teenagers. Isaiah and his friends agree to attend school, but Isaiah is sent to a remote wing an area built especially to train and nurture godlings like himself. Soon, Isaiah, the lowest rated god, finds himself pitted against some of the top gods of the other pantheons, but all he is looking for is to get revenge against his father, Zeus.

The concept for Pantheons is interesting and engaging, as the reader never knows where the story will go next. Unfortunately, it is also riddled with plot devices that just do not make sense. First, if all of the gods are teenagers, how can they have children who are also teenagers? This is never explained. Also, characters who are introduced and seem important in the first half of the book just seem to fade away by the second as new characters are introduced, and there is not real resolution to most of the storyline.

The biggest problem, though, was that Isaiah is ranked last among all the gods of the ten pantheons and the godlings, and this makes him number 135. Counting major and minor gods (and since Isaiah's mother was a minor god, I am assuming Dabel meant to include major and minor gods in this number), there are over 300 in the Greek pantheon alone. If only major gods from the ten pantheons were in the count, then the 135 number might be possible, but Isaiah would have been considered a (very) minor god, so, if that were the case, he would not have a ranking, and neither would the rest of the godlings.

With some reworking and tightening, Pantheons could be a unique story that would engage young teenagers. E. J. Dabel obviously has further books planned, so some of the characters might come back and loose ends might be wrapped up later, but with such an uneven start, I am worried that many readers will not stick around for Isaiah's further adventures.

Note: Opinions expressed in reviews and articles on this site are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of BookLoons.

Find more Teens books on our Shelves or in our book Reviews